The Voice of the Iron Mines: Thomas Gavan Duffy’s Fight Against the "Dust of Death"
Thomas Gavan Duffy (1867–1932) was a pivotal figure in the industrial and political history of West Cumbria. As a trade union leader and Member of Parliament, he became the voice of the Cumbrian iron ore miners during an era of significant social upheaval and industrial danger.
Early Roots and Education
Born on 25 September 1867 in Dublin, Ireland, Thomas Gavan Duffy was raised in a period of intense Irish political consciousness. He was educated by the Christian Brothers in Dublin, an upbringing that likely instilled in him the disciplined, oratorical, and community-focused traits that would later define his career in England.
He was the son of Sir Charles Gavan Duffy and his third wife, Louise Hall. His siblings included other notable figures like George Gavan Duffy (an Irish politician) and Louise Gavan Duffy (a prominent educator).
Duffy’s personal life is a fascinating contrast to his public visibility. While he was a titan of the trade union movement and a Member of Parliament, he was famously private.
- Duffy married Mary Jane (born in Shipton).
- His daughter was called Lilian Gowland (born in West Derby, Liverpool).
The Shop Assistants Union
Before finding his calling in the mines of Cumberland, he began his career in the service sector, serving as a district delegate for the Shop Assistants' Union. This early exposure to labour organisation provided the foundation for his move to the industrial north of England.
During the 1880s and 1890s, retail work was notoriously exploitative, characterised by the "living-in system." Shop assistants were often required to live in dormitories provided by their employers, which were frequently cramped, poorly ventilated, and used to exert total social control over the workers.
Because of his education and his family's political background, Gavan Duffy was naturally inclined toward organisation. He did not start as a labourer, but as a "District Delegate" - essentially a travelling professional organiser.
His primary focus was the "Early Closing" movement. Shops in Dublin and Belfast frequently stayed open until 10:00 PM or midnight on Saturdays. Gavan Duffy organised boycotts and public meetings to demand a 6:00 PM or 7:00 PM closing time, arguing that the "mental and physical health" of the assistants was being sacrificed for "the convenience of the late-night shopper."
In the late 1890s, the Shop Assistants’ Union began a massive recruitment drive in the industrial North of England. Gavan Duffy was sent across the Irish Sea to spearhead this expansion.
His job was to organise the men and women working in the burgeoning Co-operative stores and high-street drapers in Lancashire and the North West.
Unlike miners, who had a natural solidarity born of shared danger, shop assistants were often isolated and seen as "respectable" workers who were harder to unionise. Gavan Duffy had to use logic, legalistic arguments, and sharp oratory to convince them that they were, in fact, "workers" deserving of a 60-hour week (down from the then-standard 80+ hours).
It was during his time with the Shop Assistants that he developed the tactics he would later perfect in Moor Row.
The Shift To Miners
By 1907, Gavan Duffy was a "troubleshooter" for the wider labour movement. The Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' Association was in total disarray due to a split between the leadership and the men.
The miners needed a leader who:
- Was an outsider (to avoid local pit rivalries).
- Was a brilliant administrator (to fix the union’s broken finances).
- Was a technical expert (to navigate the new industrial safety laws).
Gavan Duffy’s success with the Shop Assistants made him the ideal candidate. He brought a "white-collar" administrative discipline to a "blue-collar" industry. When he arrived in Moor Row, he didn't look like a miner; he looked like a professional manager, which is exactly why the mine owners initially underestimated him - much to their later regret.
Having fought against the "dusty" and "unventilated" conditions of Victorian shops and warehouses, he was hypersensitive to the ventilation issues in the West Cumbrian mines, leading to his lifelong crusade against silicosis
Beliefs: The Humanitarian Advocate
Gavan Duffy’s beliefs were rooted in a mix of Irish nationalism and Independent Labour Party (ILP) socialism. He believed the miner was not just a tool of production but a man whose health was being systematically destroyed for profit.
He was the first major figure in the region to campaign against "dry rock-drilling." He argued passionately - both in Moor Row and later in Parliament - that the dust from these drills was a silent killer.
While the government of the day dismissed "Miners' Phthisis" (silicosis) as a myth in iron mines, Gavan Duffy collected evidence from the widows of Moor Row and Cleator Moor to prove the lethal nature of the work.
Temporary Offices in Moor Row (1907–1911)
When Gavan Duffy first arrived in Moor Row to take over the union in 1907, he faced a hostile environment. His predecessor, James Flynn, had refused to vacate the original union offices and had set up a rival organisation.
As a result, Gavan Duffy worked from temporary offices in Moor Row. During this period, he lived in lodgings within the village to maintain a constant presence among the miners and to physically "rebuild" the union lodge by lodge.
These early years were defined by a nomadic, grassroots style of leadership as he moved between the village's terraced streets to recruit members.
Census data from 1911, has Gavan Duffy at Alva House, in Moor Row. Here his power is consolidated in the official headquarters of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' and Kindred Trades' Association.
- The Home-Office Model: In keeping with the tradition of the time, Alva House served as both his professional headquarters and his primary residence.
- Symbolic Importance: Living at the heart of the village was a deliberate choice. It positioned him physically between the miners’ homes and the pits, ensuring he was the first person they saw during a strike or a mining accident.
- The "General's" Quarters: From this address, he managed the union's complex investments and drafted the fiery articles for his union journal, The Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' Gazette.
As the union grew, Gavan Duffy expanded its administrative reach. By 1914, the union was able to open additional offices in Bowthorn (a small settlement between Moor Row and Cleator Moor). In his later years, specifically during and after his time as an MP (1922–1924), he moved his personal residence to Cleator Moor. This move reflected his transition from a local organiser to a regional political figure. He remained in Cleator Moor until his death in 1932, though he continued to be synonymous with the "Moor Row" era of the union's history.
Political Career: MP for Whitehaven
Gavan Duffy was a staunch member of the Independent Labour Party (ILP). After an unsuccessful attempt in 1918, he was elected as the Member of Parliament for Whitehaven in the 1922 general election.
Although he held the seat only until 1924, his time in Westminster was marked by a relentless focus on the welfare of his Cumbrian constituents.
In the House of Commons, he was known for his fiery and persistent questioning of the Secretary for Mines.
He was particularly focused on:
- Improving safety inspections in the West Cumbrian haematite mines.
- Challenging the government on the "seniority" and training of mine inspectors.
- Advocating for better housing conditions for miners in the villages surrounding Whitehaven.
The Fight Against the "Dust of Death"
Gavan Duffy’s primary crusade in Parliament was against dry rock-drilling. In the 1920s, the introduction of pneumatic drills significantly increased productivity but also created clouds of fine silica dust.
- The Clash: On 7 March 1923, Gavan Duffy challenged the Secretary for Mines, Lieut.-Colonel Lane-Fox, demanding to know why dry drills were still permitted when medical experts condemned them.
- The Argument: He argued that the dust was "detrimental to the health of the men" and advocated for the mandatory use of "centra-bored spray water-drills." These drills pumped water through the centre of the bit to suppress dust at the point of impact.
- The Government’s Dismissal: The Secretary for Mines repeatedly cited a 1919 medical inquiry which claimed there was "no evidence" of long-term ill effects in Cumbrian haematite mines. Gavan Duffy famously refused to accept this, highlighting that the miners were dying in their homes in West Cumbria, far from the eyes of London-based medical committees.
Challenging the Mine Inspectorate
Gavan Duffy was highly critical of the government's oversight. He believed the inspectors sent to West Cumbria lacked the practical experience required to understand the unique dangers of haematite (iron ore) mining compared to coal mining.
His persistence on issues eventually helped pave the way for modern industrial health and safety standards in the UK.
The Case of Mr G. Cook: In March 1923, Duffy publicly questioned the qualifications of the inspector assigned to West Cumberland. He pointed out that the inspector had "no training in haematite iron-ore mines" before joining the inspectorate, arguing that nine years of "observing" as an inspector was no substitute for the hands-on training his union members possessed.
The Shift in Tools: He spoke eloquently about the transition from the traditional "hammer and jumper" (manual drilling) to modern shot-firing. He argued that the speed of modern mining was outpacing the safety regulations, turning the pits into "death traps" for the sake of higher output.
Advocacy for the "Middle-Aged" Miner
Duffy was deeply concerned with the economic lifespan of his men. In May 1923, he took on the Minister of Labour regarding the Cleator Moor Employment Exchange. He accused the exchange managers of "stopping the unemployment benefit from iron-ore miners who have passed middle age" because they refused to take gruelling labouring work that paid significantly less than their trade.
He argued that after decades of breathing mine dust, these men were physically incapable of the heavy surface work being forced upon them, effectively calling for a primitive form of industrial disability recognition.
The "Shot-Firer" Controversy
In a major debate on 24 July 1923, Gavan Duffy highlighted a specific mine in Egremont. He described how the mine owners had replaced skilled miners with a new grade of worker called a "shot-firer."
He argued that by de-skilling the workforce and relying on explosives and dry drills, the owners were increasing the risk of "explosions and falls of ground."
His technical knowledge of the mines - gained from his time at Alva House in Moor Row - allowed him to speak with an authority that often left government ministers scrambling for their notes.
He became known as a "technical" MP, capable of debating the specifics of mine ventilation and inspector qualifications with a level of detail that often embarrassed the Secretary for Mines. He was a voice for the "forgotten" metalliferous (non-coal) miners, who often fell through the cracks of national safety legislation.
Later Years and Legacy
The decline of the iron ore industry and the broader economic shifts of the late 1920s saw his union eventually merge into the National Union of General and Municipal Workers in 1929.
Thomas Gavan Duffy died on 4 August 1932. He is remembered in West Cumbria not just as a politician, but as a "Union Master" who combined Irish oratorical passion with a shrewd, modern approach to industrial relations.
His impact on Moor Row was profound. He helped the village find its identity as a unified, disciplined community. When the local mines were at their peak, his presence ensured that the railway workers and miners of Moor Row were among the best-represented labourers in the country.
Today, Alva House still stands in Moor Row as a quiet monument to the man who turned a small Cumbrian village into a powerhouse of industrial reform.
OBITUARY:
(Published in The Tablet, 13 August 1932)
Born in Dublin five-and-sixty years ago, Thomas Gavan-Duffy spent most of his active life in England, and ended it in his English home at Cleator Moor on August 4.
For two years (1922-4) he was Labour M.P. for the Whitehaven Division.
During the War he rendered valuable services to the Government in cross-examining German prisoners from captured “U-boat” submarines; and he cheerfully spent many hours, after long and tiring days in the office, at the Army Huts at Victoria, doing what he could for the comfort and welfare of soldiers on short leave.
His simplicity and frankness in coming to and dealing with “the point” often put what had appeared to be insurmountable difficulties into their true perspectives, with the result that those who consulted him went away realising that they were, after all, only facing the ordinary problems of life.
His interests were his family and his work; his hobbies his work and visits on pilgrimage to seats of Catholicity and shrines of devotion. In his last illness he occupied his mind by recalling the pilgrimages he had made, and, the day before he died, when saying how he would be unable to make a pilgrimage to Lourdes in September, which he had proposed, he expressed unutterable gratitude at having been privileged to have visited this shrine, to which he was devoted.
His last days were marked by utter reconciliation to suffering and by an eager desire to obey the call from his Maker. - R.I.P."
 |
| Thomas Gavan Duffy Illustration |
Comments
Post a Comment
Comments are welcome. Spam will not be tolerated. Strictly no advertising.