Scalegill Hall: A West Cumbrian Landmark Awaiting Revival

Perched in the West Cumbrian countryside, near the village of Moor Row, stands Scalegill Hall, a magnificent but melancholic Grade II listed building that whispers tales of centuries past.

Today, this true local landmark presents a picture of faded glory, in desperate need of a new chapter to save its historic fabric.

A History Etched in Stone

Scalegill Hall is believed to have been established in the early 17th century (Jacobean period), with ancillary outbuildings potentially dating back as far as 1615. This places its founding firmly within the region's earlier agrarian and landowning history, predating the industrialisation that would later define Moor Row.

The main house, a large rendered structure, saw a significant Georgian remodelling in the 18th century. This involved raising the roof and refronting the façade to achieve the popular classical symmetry of the era.

  • Elevated Position: The Hall occupies a high position, affording extensive views towards the sea—a characteristic placement for gentry residences of the time.
  • Industrial Contrast: Its establishment significantly predates the mid-to-late 19th-century boom of iron ore mining and railway development that transformed Moor Row into a busy industrial hub. The Hall's survival starkly illustrates the shift from a landowning gentry society to a Victorian working-class industrial economy.
  • Architectural Features: Despite years of neglect, the Hall retains original details, including an impressive decorative architrave around the front door.

Statutory Protection

The Hall's national importance is formally recognised by its statutory protection:

  • Grade II Listed Building: The primary structure and adjoining barn hold a Grade II listing, mandating strict controls over any proposed alterations or demolition.
  • Dual Listing: Intrinsically linked to the Hall, the Garden Walls to the South and West are also separately Grade II listed, emphasising that the setting is a crucial part of the heritage asset.

The Mechanism of Decline

Sadly, the Hall has stood empty for some time and is now in a "very poor state," requiring "considerable repairs and renewal."

The main reason for its falling out of use was a logistical disaster: the construction or expansion of the busy A595 road effectively severed the farm complex. The high-volume road became a permanent barrier, separating the Hall from the majority of its associated farmland. This functional difficulty led the tenant farmer to relocate, leaving the residence vacant and vulnerable to neglect and decay.

The building retains much of its valuable original 17th and 18th-century fabric, but its degraded condition means that restoration requires specialist, high-cost conservation work - creating a substantial conservation deficit.

A Future in the Balance: Redevelopment Plans

Despite the challenges, there is hope for Scalegill Hall’s future. To generate the enormous capital needed to fund the specialist restoration, developers are proposing an enabling development strategy.

Recent planning applications typically include:

  • Full Refurbishment of the Grade II listed Scalegill Hall, restoring the primary structure to its former splendour.
  • Conversion of the listed barn into new dwellings.
  • Outline Planning for new residential development on surrounding land, with the income from the new homes cross-subsidising the expensive conservation work.

The Planning Conflict

Crucially, this plan is complicated by a conflict in local policy. The Hall and approximately 7.5 hectares of surrounding land are currently designated as "future employment land" in the Copeland Local Plan, strategically safeguarded for the expansion of the adjoining Westlakes Science and Technology Park.

For any residential development to be approved, the developers must demonstrate "exceptional circumstances" where the immense public benefit of saving the heritage asset (the Hall) outweighs the loss of allocated employment land. The successful redevelopment of Scalegill Hall hinges on this complex planning negotiation.

Scalegill Hall remains a compelling example of a magnificent country house awaiting a new lease of life as an integral piece of West Cumbrian history.

Scalegill Hall Moor Row IllustrationScalegill Hall Moor Row Illustration
Location: Moor Row CA24, UK

Comments

Post a Comment

Comments are welcome. Spam will not be tolerated. Strictly no advertising.

MOST READ

About Moor Row

Image
Hello, and welcome. This site is about the village of Moor Row in West Cumbria. The history of Moor Row is one intrinsically linked to the industrial boom that transformed West Cumbria. While the area's roots stretch back to before 1762, when the homesteads of Low Moor Row and High Moor Row dotted the landscape between Summerhill Mansion and Woodend with Cleator, the true genesis of the modern village lies in iron ore and the mighty railway.  From Homestead to Hub The early landscape was characterised by family landholdings, such as the estate of the Wildridge family at Low Moor Row, located on what would become Church Street. The marriage of Elizabeth Wildridge to the local gardener, Dalzell, and his subsequent inheritance of the estates, is a pivotal local event. This link is preserved today, not just through family lore but in the village's street names, a testament to the enduring influence of the early landowners. The Railway Catalyst The mid-19th century witnessed an expl...
Read more

Beneath the Surface: The Forgotten Iron Giant

Image
If you were to walk through the quiet streets of Moor Row today, you might find it hard to believe that this West Cumbrian village was once the beating heart of a massive industrial operation. Beneath the modern pavement and suburban gardens lies the legacy of the Montreal Mines - an enterprise that once rivalled the giants of the industry. While the mine closed in the 1920s, its footprint remains massive, fascinating, and occasionally dangerous. Let’s dig into the history of the Montreal Mines.  An Industrial Powerhouse At its peak, the Montreal Mines were nothing short of a colossus in the iron ore industry.  Producing an impressive 250,000 tons of ore a year, it was the most productive mine in the entire Whitehaven or Furness district, second only to the legendary Hodbarrow mine. The scale of the operation was immense: The Land : The property covered 1,000 acres, with half of that land being rich in iron ore. The Workforce : It wasn't just machines; it was men. Between 1,00...
Read more

Moor Row's Enduring Spirit: A Legacy of Sacrifice in Two World Wars

Image
Nestled in the heart of West Cumbria, the seemingly quiet village of Moor Row holds a history far richer and more poignant than its present-day tranquility might suggest. Like countless communities across the United Kingdom, Moor Row played its part in the monumental struggles of the two World Wars, contributing its sons and daughters to the fight for freedom and peace. The echoes of their sacrifice still resonate today, etched into the very fabric of the village, most notably in the solemn presence of its War Memorial. The Great War : A Village Answers the Call When the call to arms came in 1914, Moor Row, then a bustling mining community, responded with unwavering resolve. Young men, many working in the local pits or related industries, swapped their tools for rifles and their civilian clothes for military uniforms.  Families bid tearful goodbyes, understanding the gravity of the situation but perhaps not fully comprehending the immense scale of the conflict that lay ahead. The t...
Read more

The Village: History, Growth, and Erosion of Amenities

Image
The village of Moor Row, a residential community between Whitehaven and Egremont on the Cumbrian coastal plain, essentially owes its existence to the 19th-century iron ore boom.  Originally known by various names, including Low Keekle and Moor Row Junction, the community expanded rapidly from what was initially just a scattering of homesteads.  Founding Streets and Industrial Heritage The village name itself probably refers to the houses on Scalegill Street (or Scalegill Road), which were noted on the 1860 Ordnance Survey map and represent some of the original development. The definitive oldest terraced housing, however, is believed to be the row of two-up, two-down cottages built in 1859 on Dalzell Street. This street is particularly significant, named after the prominent Dalzell family, who owned parcels of land in the area and were connected to the local gentry and mine owners (specifically Thomas Henry Dalzell). Another street, Penzance Street, directly reflects the large-...
Read more

Moor Row: Starting the Adventure on Wainwright’s Coast to Coast Walk

Image
The Coast to Coast (C2C) walk is one of the UK’s most celebrated long-distance paths, the brainchild of the legendary fellwalker and writer, Alfred Wainwright. Spanning approximately 190 miles from the Irish Sea to the North Sea, it’s a trek filled with breathtaking landscapes, from the craggy peaks of the Lake District to the gentle undulations of the Yorkshire Wolds. But every epic journey must begin somewhere, and for the traditional western start, that place is usually the unassuming Cumbrian village of St Bees. Yet, the very first few miles - the section that takes you inland from the sea - often involves a necessary, but perhaps less-glamorous, stretch that takes you right through the former mining village of Moor Row. The Start : After dipping your boots in the Irish Sea at St Bees and picking up a pebble to carry to Robin Hood’s Bay (a lovely tradition!), the walk begins with a stunning, clifftop amble. The first sight of the coastline and the distant Isle of Man on a clear day...
Read more